WELCOME TO OUR "WHAT'S NEW! PAGE
​
On this page, you find a chronological list of what we have been doing over the past while.
​
Provincial Election 26 November 2024
With a PC majority, here is the position that guides NSDFA in dealing with concerns about the net pens near Bayswater:
​​
"We understand the concerns that have been raised from members of the Twin Bays Coalition regarding the environment at Bayswater Beach Provincial Park. As referenced in your email, two scientific reports have been submitted to the public on this topic. Both of these reports conclusively prove that the material found on the Beach is not the same as the organic material found under fish farms. The PC Government is committed to addressing environmental concerns, working with communities to ensure healthy and sustainable ecosystems. We feel the reports referenced above are evidence of this commitment. At this time, we do not intend to investigate this matter further."
​
​Here is what led to the PC position:
BACKGROUND provided:
In 2019, Cermaq Canada was investigating an open net pen aquaculture option to lease extending from St. Margaret's Bay to Green Bay. Twin Bays Coalition was formed at that time to improve public awareness of this method of aquaculture. Cermaq declined the option to lease because they could not find suitable waters in Nova Scotia to support their proposed operations.
There is one open net pen site operating in our area, near Bayswater Beach Provincial Park. It has been operating for decades. In 2018, the site was moved closer to populated areas. This was done with the approval of government bureaucrats but without the legislated review process that includes an opportunity for public input.
In 2019, residents observed black material on the beach and a significant increase in the sulphurous smell on the beach that can occasionally occur naturally.
They reported this to Government and were redirected seven different times to various Departments and agencies with no answers or willingness to investigate the cause of these changes. The fact that currents in the waters flowing through the open net pens were headed to Bayswater Beach Provincial Park was downplayed as a possible cause for the pollution.
In 2020, as the salmon in the net pens approached maturity, conditions were so bad on the beach that gases were bubbling up through the sand, large stretches of the beach was black and people and dogs were feeling ill on the beach. One retired scientist who visited the beach said that he had only seen one area more severely impacted in his career and that was a beach in New Brunswick that was surrounded by open net pens.
In 2021, a report was produced by the Province that determined the open net pens were not to blame for the changes at the beach. That report did not include any public consultation, participation or local knowledge. A scientifically substantiated request for further Government study was then made. Omissions and errors in the report were pointed out to the Province. This included a Municipal study that contradicts the findings of the Provincial study.
To this day, the Government has refused to commission another study or respond to the omissions and errors present in the 2021 Provincial report. Meanwhile, Bayswater Beach Provincial Park and the surrounding area continue to be plagued with black sand and strong smells at low tide, especially after storms.
​
September 2022 to June 2024
The Bayswater open net pens were emptied in Spring of 2023 and the site was empty until early July 2024. The effect of the site on the sand that moves on and off the beach lingers.
​
Two years later and we still await the results of the Regulatory Review. Over 1000 individuals and organizations made the effort of providing input to the Government. For the most part, they were not endorsements of the existing Regs.
​
Twin Bays Coalition has regularly sent letters to politicians on many issues of concern to Bayswater Beach Provincial Park. We're working on a summary of those efforts for you.
​
27 June 2024 - Media Conference at the Wooden Monkey in Dartmouth. Excellent panelists and great coverage. A big thank you to all! Here are some links:
Here is some coverage associated with this event:
CBC Nova Scotia News – Go to the 11:50 mark on the 27 June broadcast.
May to August 2022
​
REGULATORY REVIEW
Twin Bays participated as a stakeholder in the Provincial aquaculture regulatory review process. We did so via a verbal interview in June and followed up with two written submissions. Public submissions were invited through an on-line survey. Twin Bays drafted a three page survey response document and circulated it with the request to have maximum participation.
BOOK LAUNCH
Salmon Wars – the book, was released and events were planned to launch the book and raise awareness of significant expansion plans for open net pens in Nova Scotia waters. We hope to meet you at one of these events!
March to April 2022
FOIPOP REQUESTS
​
Several Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy requests have been made for information on the economic impact of open net pens and correspondence between the operator and the Government about expanding the Saddle Island site. The economic data provided was nothing more than promotional material for industry and we are still deciding on the $500.00 bill to do the correspondence search about the expansion.
STUDY
​
Twin Bays worked with Coastal Action to support a study on Bayswater Beach being funded by the Municipality of the District of Chester. Results confirm that the pond is not causing the changes on the beach.
OUT OF BOUNDS
​
The boundary infraction complaint Twin Bays filed with Government was suspended until the results of the Aquaculture Review Board hearing on the “proposed” expansion at the Saddle Island site (which has already taken place). They declined to press charges against the operator despite acknowledging that two open net pens are outside of the lease boundary and have produced about 270,000 salmon over two growth cycles.
January to February 2022
​
CHANGES TO THE AQUACULTURE REVIEW BOARD
​
We sent a letter to the Minister of the NS Department of Fisheries and Aquaculture and local MLAs asking for changes to the Aquaculture Review Board. Changes were for funding for intervenors, admissibility of evidence on boundary infractions, local impacts and other matters which should concern the Board.
MEETINGS
​
We met with our MP, Rick Perkins, MLA Danielle Barkhouse and NS Minister for Economic Development the Honourable Susan Corkum-Greek and had productive discussions about the aims of the Twin Bays Coalition and the Healthy Bays Network.
​
MORE LETTERS
​
A Letter of Concern was sent to Federal authorities under the Canadian Navigable Waters Act in response to an application by the Saddle Island site for an approval to expand (which has already taken place). No response has been received by Twin Bays.
​
A request was made to the Minister for an update on our letter from September 2021 where we outlined concerns about the Provincial Study that attributed the conditions at Bayswater Beach to the pond. The matter was referred to the Science Advisory Committee, but our September letter was not forwarded to the Committee. In essence, our concerns have been completely ignored.
​
PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT
​
Twin Bays participated in a highly successful, on-line forum hosted by the Ecology Action Centre regarding the conduct of the Aquaculture Review Board.
17 January 2022
​
We have been running a social media campaign to generate awareness and opposition to the planned expansion of site 1006, an open net pen finfish site near Bayswater Beach. Here are the posts that we have made so far:
1. Effects on Bayswater Beach Provincial Park:
This is the first of a series of posts to generate opposition to an open net pen finfish aquaculture site near Bayswater Beach Provincial Park located on the Aspotogan Peninsula between Mahone Bay and St. Margaret’s Bay.
​
The site has been expanded outside of approved lease boundaries without the formal review and approval of the Aquaculture Review Board (ARB).
​
The ARB is an independent decision-making body appointed and funded by Government. They hear applications for new aquaculture sites and expansion of finfish sites such as the one near Bayswater Beach. Public input is encouraged at these Hearings. Hearing dates for this site have not yet been announced.
​
Please watch our video that shows the effects that we believe have been caused by this unapproved expansion and check out our website at twinbays.ca for more details. https://drive.google.com/.../122fwX.../view...
​
2. Twin Bays Coalition Update - What have we been up to???:
This is the second in a series of posts to generate opposition to an open net pen finfish aquaculture site near Bayswater Beach Provincial Park located on the Aspotogan Peninsula between Mahone Bay and St. Margaret’s Bay.
​
It’s been two years since a large group of concerned citizens gathered at the Mahone Bay Centre to learn more about the impacts of open net pen finfish farming. Much has been accomplished since then.
​
Here is a short video that describes our Twin Bays Coalition (TBC) activities and other work. It may take a few seconds to load. Please visit our website at twinbays.ca for full details and share our posts with your friends. Thanks, from TBC!
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Wsc4yZExB6AZ5bbre76WO_lq-vlyr03C/view?usp=sharing
​
3. The Aquaculture Review Board - Review the Review Board:
This is the third of a series of posts to generate opposition to an open net pen finfish aquaculture site near Bayswater Beach Provincial Park located on the Aspotogan Peninsula between Mahone Bay and St. Margaret’s Bay.
​
Minister Craig has initiated a review of our aquaculture legislation and regulations. Regrettably, he indicates that legislation and regulations establishing the Aquaculture Review Board (ARB) will not be reviewed.
​
After only one finfish ARB Hearing, there is ample evidence that this tribunal is fatally flawed.
​
Please watch our latest video describing why the ARB and the open net pen finfish approval process needs to be included in the Nova Scotia aquaculture review and visit our website at twinbays.ca Stay tuned for some simple suggestions to correct these problems.
https://drive.google.com/.../1BD6Ixb0Z4.../view...
Here is a copy of the script for this video:
https://drive.google.com/.../19tQsFKJZknKwbWCRqqH.../view...
There is also a great summary of public participation in these ARB Hearings at:
https://www.ecelaw.ca/.../Aquaculture_Summary_Series_Jan...
For full details on the ARB, they have a web page at:
​
Federal Aquaculture Act Submission: The Aquaculture Act is a new piece of proposed legislation governing the growing aquaculture sector. Our submission highlighted the need to mandate approval by those most affected by new aquaculture proposals; namely, local residents.
5 January 2022
Here are links to some of our initiatives and work mentioned in the TBC Update video:
The provincial Minister of Fisheries and Aquaculture wanted to significantly increase the size and powers of the three person Aquaculture Review Board through Bill 24 - An Act to Amend the Fisheries and Coastal Resources Act. Several submissions were made to the Law Amendments Committee. Go to the link and scroll down to the 25 October 2021 table and look for Bill 24.